Powell v Texas

Facts

Powell was a chronic alcoholic. He was convicted in Texas of being found intoxicated in a public place and fined. He said the appearance was involuntary because of his condition.

Issue

Is it cruel to punish a chronic alcoholic for being found drunk in public?

Held

The United States Supreme Court affirmed the conviction. He was punished for being found drunk in a public place, not for the status of being an alcoholic.

Principle

A manifestation of a condition in a public place can be punished even where the condition itself could not.

Why it matters

It draws the line between a pure status and conduct that manifests the status.

For study only. By lanbuk.com. Always check current sources and consult a qualified professional.