Allie Bendu v Grant S. Bendu Kamara (CIV APP 2 of 1976) [1977] SLSC 8 (25 October 1977)

bj Bie Heumersble Goiot guotiee €.0% ene = Fronsding i ‘he Honvewuble ie, Justies

2. Mvessy Luke = Justiec of the e ‘Suprete Court 4 + The Tiwnoureide tir, Justice CA. Karding - Justice of the 7 ; ‘Suprono Court (tho cmarabis tire sustiee Kyle During ~ dusteo of Append af The Thamrste fir, ducties 45, Davis = Justice of Appeal i] civid typai Bo. 2/76 8 wie tiny = areenint } 4s “3 } tor sazent 4 Grant fall sundu Kesar Respondent} ‘ JEbeRREe 25th eteber, 1977. Fn nl pony, tage Gubieitor 257 the fapedant + oo, tg Hamling J. ae es ‘The Rempomlsns heroin, Grant Sal Bunda Karnse, Scat tacan, 1964, vortnged in froshond property H.2ID te Streak, | proctowa to tho Dovotomoort of Toustrice nnd (DED, for short) to 1g por one por anim payable oa 44h Hareh, 1965; the montage vas | cerectot uy a eamerme’ of to ankd vropirty 40 tn Hortgngoe aubjoot A to a proving fer rehuption, 2n 22nd July 1964, £.0 before the date | ssiudl tor veuception, ons AlLis Dundu (the Appelant herein) a Judgront | reat tor of dzent 52018 itera Kanara (the Hertgager) 4m exccution of the haunuxn debe, yurpsrtud 80 pazebnae eho opentont'a equity of donee pica nthe sortingo! gooyerty at an austion ano by the SaHtEE of suorrs wowin ds water auton § of Us Fxocubion Ainat Kool Proporty ‘Ka tole Yoana

ri os WY eras, 14%, aikie dundu an cxoeution eroditer took —° Fo ott Oriectiae i: as Wigan a tesa tb Bata) [8 Who SherHEE an. as auton ‘ata/iespontente, praying for an Order PBA He Dede (the that) de abe a Dood of Heluase of the J OTHFOS mwtcee 5. bin Rovume span pricunt ty the terkft te the [P23 ob Ge tatnans she sertpgs QL nal intern daw and ving TMU PSeRIGE U's ots abe anes-en wee eupported by an affidavit evorn gNORF Eh omplest. a tortmarr tos the fomyendmt homin, wan not uate a erty te thons yrous utes ‘The wetter ewe uy before Doble, Js on 2ist Jaminry, 1966, sil no yA ction teving ben ido by the Soldettnmduwead wie ob the tine Ferevevntod loth the D.d.i, snd tho ShareSt, an Ondsr, a waa prayed, was Weido accordingly. Oh 2nd itay, 1966, the DeLuibe in corpliance vith His oaid Order duly exventca a Duod of Alone of the nertenged prenteon ts favour ef, Che capsttont. In teat awe yon tue Respondent whe had bem tu pormston oF ite oniaisos wan evleted therefrar by tho cppoltalt "-siiaorfautiv, ia 1970, th Hoopendent Anstttuted roccodings $n tie {U8 Sous syne: oh. ME, oad on Sth Oebetor 1977 Swomuctiarke J, fer ie titan ros} oie “2 Ole ow FoMhewse

2. Metowie oP skys Aated 2d Hey 1966 by the i: Bofondit (fc. the Bitcie} 8 oe SMS0 nde ‘ of Uy Plakntittt coterie vecperty ei tunte at BrP Mon AM AW SURE crete da bad im Yen sed tat) ed wei, 2, tke gmat eamymnes Lewnafor of the Loyd faa Siuply of the Anintittte ald sortianal property + by the Refevtant to on: A1Ie stmda hy way of a Purported Asano of Howtirws dated 2nd Hayy 1965 do oot atte. Je Me Lounduals do romstoner 9 tle aLasMEE the Pisccifftn aid sovtyjel property pwreninan and Lend pitevts nt asd ine a 21D Us Strvot, ' Mi,

artcaety ems Ue Joystdat- am wet nude a party te those” procoudl econ inch he atm) ohint man AuNy eongatzant of the fuet that the dppcdlant wes thon in penasesion of the pronisce.

Ts 49 tuofore st auxpriaing thet the tosrondent found 4 Bevin, im IGT, Uo institute fuetier jruecadinge agulaat beth the BEB. and tho was Viis claising: « remweymes to hii of the aortic ProeTty od much Tortter or othar sulief, ‘The eae uns honed by Yare> fe oa Ye Woot or) caod by oo 25th SF mmry 19M, ve Sudpent Gsniasing thos pendants elain ath conta, On appial by the Reaponturt B the Court of Sigesh (Cane Majin Juthee, ZMmomRennor Joke and 8.2. Bovioe Joe) he Jeo oF ings Jy wm gt cole anh an Order nade for the Weapoatont (sie os Ugre threds) to hors Inf the costs both in Brit Court and i the Tigh Court, cgsthint tte deetaion the Zppelant foroia bes appoodel te is Gaurts

Jn Ria Atatinant of elak* filed da the igh Court, the Rempondont P averred net onl, tis jetaysa of swmectianke J. (above-nentionst) but | aso the cxcoution te i af the certiuse deed oF 4th thereh, 2961 in favour

of the DAFsi, (yho ae. the Ast Dofordants 4 Wat aetion) and the

F eusooqiont saossa on Piet Kay, 1966 of tho sid nartenge to the kppelant

J utthour hia (soapaudcat's) eouwoe. a furttur alleged that the DAT.I. ait | ot nt any tine boten the anid 4th any of fareh 962 and the said 2nd | say of waren 2086 amiadon en o€ Lin atght wnat She Sid nortan

| seetuting the right te Fervekencs oF th contrary, the Dufvy contimot

| se esate favs bie duatedrent ropcurumta of tho Lenn up to And snetuding

© verter, 19564. {Lisong the roeuints tundorod sn support of such

| sopuyonte ues ono Aseud 27th Jsousry, 396807

tho Taade, tn suois Dofenes filed, norely ataitted the exzeution

of tm,satd nortgige “wh thy mubeeyent melsaow thereat te the Kipodnt, Tho ayyodtone (ts Gok Aofunbant La thy aetton) in his snondea pefenes gontud tht ahs wapendact sa) wnbleled ether 4m awe or 40 eyuity to 4 roenweysies 0 Hh yewiizon and abated that the Roeprndent te equlay of retention” wna noki uy pebiie naction andor avo pracone of hiv to ontdety 3 jatgit Jobe agisant tho Boapendent and Ghat By suah sate ws Hoapewtse ww tia ght tO naiand tha PrOBOFEY ond ERE Cho oe awe Horse? blew aunragited te, oF in ie Vivien

subatitutlen of, ti righia of Gho inmatant to moon’ ths nertinged wroporty. Ho sic plated the Galay of Boobs J. dated 2tet Jnauaryy 2865, onturine: Uo DvLAi, io mizh a Mooi of solene of the norteno? In Wie fren nj vst by the Shorith to the Rete of tho norton dest cat antmit Gon die ose) Gols. Us furthse atated that in emp Usneo vith te ssi@ rder thy Daly daly unventod the Dood of F atone. anh tinct ar un ih jeanoaudon of the proparty wader a bona £42 J tte snd We ho mos dog tty ontetled to seinin dn posseaston and tht jt Lypotdantta chats we mniunisd anv that the ation vos frivolous { wexttious aud se cian of tho proaoise of the Courts i Tho Formed Uriad duadgo $n Adnsinaing tho action add into alia ‘unctlor the Crart srusided enor by the learaod Judas : Brovnoettorts 9s. In jursaietivn to nwiow the Order of Plant Sasury 1966 fm doubtful; ourrie. £¢ to aay tint : ony shell ersider ahthor she Qnt Defendant hae a good title + to thy proparty vat Ag the oiatntite ae a roowlt of the tines rosea Sate de neds at Os ad propertse the 2nd tufstont ene S89 postoaaion by the Rood af talongy oe ented tn 1966 An yuzmames to the Onder : et-onat to bo etm inate on tho 2lot Jamary 1966 Cgounso far ate! bofonbant euntonts tht Zn Defendant poetry ay gnetiriae of the pLAAeLEt/ortengor 98 a reouit off tin ajoration of Jaw = Ghat ks to gay von hee pure se thn popurty tn execution oF the Sugnent dose horvin tofore suntionad and Morofore Bad @ right ah redo the corbgued rope Tages with ome sos thas 2nd otosindts ZH Dofsndent buesie entitled 5 of Gap. 27 of ths lin of Storms Hoene, ccnuish evmnnt by sasinl 16 an he tnd no matin ae ac ees 1 na ans thet thet D6 nl notin

The pages read for this report end here. The judgment continues in the PDF.